Skip to main content
Header image

The Comprehensive Guide to Checkweighers and X-ray Systems for Industrial Weighing

12.05.2024
10 min

Why is accurate weighing important? In food production, the answer lies in the sheer scale of operations. Consider a line processing 120 packs of granola bars per minute— roughly 57,000 packs per shift. Each pack is labeled to weigh 200 grams, but if there’s an average overfill of just 5 grams per pack, costing an additional $0.05, that small error will add up to $85,000 per month. Reducing the excess by just 2 grams per pack could save nearly $35,000 per month.

Inaccurate weighing isn't only costly in low-margin sectors like food. For high-value products such as cosmetics, cannabis, and nutraceuticals, even the smallest product giveaway can quickly drive up expenses. Underweight or incomplete products can lead to complaints and damage brand reputation as, with rising inflation, consumers are paying closer attention to getting exactly what they paid for.

In the pharmaceutical industry, product weight is also a critical safety factor. For capsules, tablets, and vials, a weight deviation of as little as 0.5 milligrams from the labeled amount could indicate an inaccurate dosage of the active ingredient. This may reduce the efficacy of the treatment or lead to adverse side effects for patients.

Another consequence of inaccurate weight is incompliance with standards and regulations. Handbook 133 by the National Institute of Standard and Technology (NIST) emphasizes the importance of using scales with appropriate accuracy levels and sets the standards for acceptable weight variations based on the type of product. These guidelines are used by the USDA and the FDA, and international food safety standards such as BRCGS and SQF.

In this guide, we’ll explore the role of two essential weighing technologies— checkweighers and X-ray systems—explaining how they ensure accurate product weighing across various industries.

Applications of Dynamic Checkweighers in Industrial Production

The first checkweigher for the food industry appeared on the market at the beginning of the previous century. Since then, the technology has continually evolved. Today, dynamic checkweighers are used in a wide range of industries for both product quality and safety purposes. For example:

  • Weighing of packaged food and pet food, from a few grams to 20+ kg
  • Automatic grading of raw products, such as seafood and vegetables
  • Weighing of individual tablets and capsules
  • Detecting missing blister packs in cartons, missing cartons in cases, or missing components in medical kits
  • Detecting leaks in pressurized aerosol canisters
  • Detecting missing accessory components in hardware packages (e.g., assembly kits for DIY furniture)

When the final weight of the products is the result of a filling process, a food industry checkweigher can enhance accuracy even further by using trend control. This feature provides feedback to the filler in real time to adjust quantities and maintain consistent product weight.

How Checkweighers Work

  • Strain gauge cells: The product's mass presses down on the weigh table, distorting the load cell. The resulting electrical signals are converted into weight readings. Strain gauge checkweighers provide accuracy up to ±0.2g and are ideal for heavier or high-throughput applications.
  • Force balance cells: These use an electromagnetic counterforce to return a displaced beam to its equilibrium position. They offer superior accuracy (±0.5 mg) and are best for lightweight products and high-speed lines.

Factors That Affect Checkweigher Accuracy

Accuracy in checkweighers is indicated with a sigma (σ) value of 2σ or 3σ, which refers to the system’s ability to consistently weigh a product accurately. If you were to weigh the same product repeatedly, sigma represents how close the weights are to one another and to the actual weight. A lower sigma value means better checkweigher accuracy.

In fact, the required accuracy of a checkweigher depends on the specific application. If you were to check 20-kg bags of pet food, an accuracy of ±2 grams would be appropriate, while checkweighing tablets demands detection of deviations as small as 0.5 mg.

In addition to the type of weigh cell, the IP rating is another design element that can influence accuracy. While higher IP ratings ensure protection against dust and moisture, they require added sealing materials that introduce friction, heat retention, and mechanical limitations that may affect accuracy of weight measurements.

Other factors influencing accuracy depend on the type of application, such as the type of product and how the production line is configured. Unlike static scales, where items are placed on a stationary weigh table, in dynamic checkweighers, products gradually pass from the infeed conveyor onto the weigh table and then move off via the outfeed conveyor. While dynamic weighing increases throughput and productivity—some models can handle up to 1,000 products per minute—, it also introduces specific challenges that can impact accuracy:

Weight time. The product needs sufficient time on the weigh table to ensure accurate readings between transfers. Weight time is determined by conveyor length, line speed, and product size. Longer conveyors, slower line speeds, and shorter products allow for longer weight times, leading to higher accuracy.

Product spacing. Insufficient spacing between products on the conveyor can cause two items to end up on the load cell simultaneously, causing incorrect readings.

Product weight. Reading accuracy increases with heavier products.

Environmental Conditions That Impact Accuracy

Environmental conditions can also diminish checkweigher accuracy:

  • Temperature fluctuations may affect the integrity of strain gauge cells.
  • Vibrations from nearby equipment can cause disturbance to the scale. This can be minimized with the use of force balance cells, which are generally more resistant to vibrations, and digital filters.
  • Wind currents introduce external forces and movements that destabilize the weigh mechanism.

Virtual Weighing with X-Ray Systems

Traditionally, X-ray systems have been used by food processing companies to detect non-metallic contaminants. However, advancements in detection and image processing have expanded their application as a weighing system.

How Virtual Weighing Works

In an X-ray system, the product goes through a tunnel where a tank on the upper side generates X-rays that scan a “slice” of the product. At the bottom, a sensor measures the energy that passes through and converts it into a greyscale image. Denser products absorb more energy, resulting in darker images.

In foreign material detection, an X-ray system will analyze the uniformity of shading within the image. In food production, for example, any foreign contaminant with higher density than the product—such as metal—appears as a darker spot and is rejected.

The system, however, can also compare the density of different images to estimate weight variations. For example, if a product should have a thickness of 50 mm, the master X-ray image of a correctly weighed product will have a shade density specified as 1. During inspection, if an image is 10% lighter, the product's thickness is 45 mm, indicating it's 10% lighter.

How virtual weighing can help your production

There are two applications where virtual weighing is particularly suitable.

Grading. With checkweighers, if a second product rolls onto the weigh table it can cause a double product error. X-ray systems can analyze two products separately within the same X-ray image, making them ideal for grading unstable products (like frozen scallops) or high-speed production lines with narrow product spacing.

Composite products. Let’s consider the example of a line producing bento boxes with four partitions. If two of the components are underweight and one is overweight, but the weight deviations compensate each other, the checkweigher will let the product pass, as the total package weight will be correct. An X-ray system, however, will compare the image to a master product and detect all three incorrect fillings.

Key Performance Factors for Virtual Weighing

In virtual weighing, it's essential that the density of the inspected product matches that of the reference product. For instance, using a master image of a butter tub to weigh margarine would likely result in inaccurate readings. Margarine is less dense than butter, meaning the X-ray image would display a lighter shade, even if the two products weigh the same. In contrast, a checkweigher would measure both products accurately regardless of density.

Additionally, virtual weighing is not suitable for applications requiring precise weight measurements, such as with medications.

Choosing the Right Weighing Solution

The choice between X-ray systems and checkweighers (and which load cell technology) depends on the type of product and what weight deviations are allowed by quality standards and regulations. Both can be effective weighing solutions, though they function differently. Checkweighers measure actual mass, while X-ray systems calculate virtual weight by comparing the density of a product with that of a known sample.

Checkweighers (especially force balance models) are the go-to solution for industries where even the slightest weight deviations—such as in pharmaceuticals—can compromise quality and safety. They are also highly effective for detecting missing items in packaged goods. X-ray systems, on the other hand, excel in cases where products are spaced too closely or where multiple components need individual verification. Since they aren't affected by multiple products on the conveyor at once, X-ray systems are well-suited for high-speed production lines or when managing unstable or composite items.

undefined

Get it right from the start