Technical Note Vol.8 June, 2014
Checkweighers' Double Product Error and Improved Productivity
When using a checkweigher, you may have experienced a sudden occurrence of a double product error. Frequent double product error can decrease productivity. This paper will focus on the error and propose a solution.
 What is a double product error?
If two packs are on the weigh table at the same time, a double product error will occur and the system is forced to reject both packs since each individual weight cannot be determined. This is called a double product error (Fig.1-1). A common solution is to increase the speed of the checkweigher's conveyor to separate the packs (Fig.1-2), or to install a feeder controller which holds up closely-spaced packs to feed them at a ﬁxed interval.
Fig. 1-1: Double products
Fig. 1-2: Belt speed adjusted
However, even with such measures, many users still get double product errors everyday because spacing is easily disturbed while the pack is traveling on the conveyor or transferring to the next conveyor.
 Pitfalls of preventive measures
What kind of problems can be caused by a double product error? When a double product error occurs, the pack is evaluated as "unmeasurable" and rejected, even when the weight is within speciﬁcations. The rejected pack must be fed to the checkweigher again if you want to ship it. But in the meantime, chilled and frozen products may be wasted.
In order to prevent this from occurring, many checkweigher users may have set the belt speed of the checkweigher higher than the upstream conveyor. However, if the belt speed becomes faster, the pack will be on the scale for shorter time, which reduces weighing accuracy. Furthermore, because of the reduced accuracy, the user needs to increase ﬁlling volume to ensure that no packs fall below the speciﬁed minimum weight. Although the ﬁlling volume increased for this purpose may look subtle, it would come to hundreds or thousands of kilograms over the year.
 Enhanced productivity with SMF
Here we introduce Anritsu checkweigher's Smart Measurement Function (SMF). It has been developed to reduce double product errors as well as product giveaway while maintaining weighing accuracy.
Then, how does SMF work? A checkweigher processes weight signals while the weight is stable (Fig. 3-1). Conventional checkweighers use only one ﬁlter and are not capable of processing signals when signals become suddenly unstable due to double products, resulting in rejecting both packs. SMF, however, processes the weight signals of only a stable phase by using a shorter weighing interval ﬁlter (Fig.3-2). Even when two packs are on the scale at the same time, no weighing error occurs.
Fig. 3-1: Good conveying condition
Fig. 3-2: Two packs on scale
Now, take a close look at the eﬀect of SMF. We conducted an experiment using a bag of cereal (Fig. 3-4), whose contents move easily in the bag and accuracy ﬂuctuates a lot. The weight of the cereal is 44.87 g.
First, we set the belt speed to 50 m/min and fed the pack 10,000 times. No double product error occurred. Next, we decreased the belt speed to 40 m/min and fed 10,000 time using SMF and then another 10,000 times without using SMF to see how much SMF saves material waste. We calculated "production loss" — a double product error involves possible product waste — and "raw material saving" by the formula shown in Fig. 3-1. "Raw material saving effect" was determined by adding production loss to raw material saving. The results of the experiment are shown in Table 3-1.
Fig. 3-3: Calculation
Fig. 3-4: Cereal
||Weighing accuracy (3σ) [g]
||Double product (piece)
||Production loss (1) [g]
||Raw material saving (2) [g]
||Raw material saving eﬀect (1+2) [g]Note2
Note 1: Even when SMF is on, weighing accuracy will not decrease if double product does not occur.
Note 2: Raw material saving eﬀect will not be seen if the amount of raw materials fed in the upstream ﬁlling machine is not reduced.
Table 3-1: ExperiAment result
In (B), where belt speed was low and SMF was not used, double product error occurred 30 times. Although its weighing accuracy was much higher than (A), the raw material saving eﬀect was only -546.10g. On the other hand, in (C), where SMF was used, double product error occurred only once, and weighing accuracy became higher than (A), resulting in the raw material saving eﬀect of 355.13g. Consequently, production eﬃciency of (C) is much higher than that of (A).
SMF helps you minimize double product error and improve productivity. SMF may not produce large effect when the product's position is less likely to be disturbed or the product weights are widely varied. However, with the increase of ready meal product production due to the changes in lifestyles and eating patterns, many food companies are expected to expand their product range. SMF will be your useful tool if you have a problem of double product error with a particular product in the feature.
Vol.8 PDF >
Technical Note (For general use) >
Products & Solutions > Weight Inspection >
Introduction of SSV series Checkweigher >
Glossary: Checkweighers >